Sharon Roulstone, the Cayman Islands Ombudsman, has reaffirmed her position on a contentious Freedom of Information dispute, declining to reverse a September decision that affects how judicial appointment records are handled. According to Cayman News Service, the Attorney General had argued the Ombudsman’s ruling was unlawful and signaled plans to pursue judicial review.
The dispute centers on access to records connected to Chief Justice Margaret Ramsay-Hale’s appointment. Roulstone’s original September ruling established that while the Judicial and Legal Services Commission itself is not subject to the Freedom of Information Act, the Commissions Secretariat—which holds or can access relevant documents—must process the request and determine whether disclosure is permitted under the Act.
In her October response, Roulstone rejected the Attorney General’s contention that her decision exceeded her authority. She clarified that her ruling does not compel the immediate release of documents but rather requires the Secretariat to conduct a proper search for responsive records and apply the legal framework governing public access to information. The distinction underscores a procedural rather than substantive mandate, allowing officials to withhold information where the law permits while ensuring the request receives proper consideration.
The Cayman Islands Ombudsman’s office investigates complaints about public administration and can review decisions under the Freedom of Information Act. The dispute reflects broader tensions in the jurisdiction over transparency in judicial appointments and the scope of records subject to public disclosure.
Judicial independence and transparent appointment processes are foundational to Caribbean governance. This dispute in the Cayman Islands illustrates ongoing regional challenges in balancing institutional autonomy with public accountability and freedom of information rights.
Sources and attribution
- Cayman Compass
- AG to fight records release over CJ post – Cayman Islands Headline News
- Cayman Islands Ombudsman Defends Freedom of Information Ruling on Judicial Records
CVCA Express Draft: verification pending; WordPress publication is manual.
